Kevin accuses Josie of ignoring her past and thus making the same mistakes she did with Mel and Val. However, since leaving the Pussycats and going solo, she has refrained from wearing the Pussycat ears. Tuxed C. Sebastian. She explains that Alex invited her and asks if Josie’s ready to do some gigs with her own music, specifically the Apollo.
He had no right to walk in like that. Jorge reveals that his parents have been under charging them for years.
However, Trula and Cricket aren’t pleased with their roles in the band. However, they need to find out who did. Even though she and Alex had a fling, Josie is focused on her career.
Pepper tells Josie that all opportunities come at a price. He meets with his sponsor often. In Josie's early years, her mother became the mayor of Riverdale, and consequently, she and her mother had to endure the hate mail and slanderous messages people were sending to them.
Josie is waiting her Pussycats at Molly's for rehearsals, but when Trula and Cricket arrive after learning about the history of the Pussycats from Kevin, there's no rehearsal. Later, Jimmy arrives at Chubby’s, where Josie gives him a "free-day-old" doughnut from her other job. He explains to Josie that he was an assistant editor on one season of the Matchelorette, so he’s used to working fast. Admittedly, Pepper lied, but Josie reminds them that Pepper is always there for them when they need her. The four of them go to Brunetti's for a pizza and Josie gets a call from Mr. Cabot’s office. He got offered a contract to compose music for TV and radio with Cabot Entertainment. The two share the stage both as Spider Woman, concluding the show with a kiss.
Alex denies that the gift was for his sister as they always buy each other Valentine's Day gifts.
Late at night, as Josie was leaving school, she came across Chuck whose presence shook her as it was dark in the hallways. Josie, Pepper and Jorge are concerned about how Katy is dealing with her break up with KO. Jorge then reveals that he had a threesome with Bernardo and Buzz. Too many times has her stepfather denigrated her. Josie, Alex, and Raj arrive at Chubby's Record Shop to find that Mr. Cabot has already hired two girls to fill the spots, Priscilla and Corinne. Josie performs on stage briefly before being joined by Jorge, who is also playing Spider Woman. While trying to get them out, Jorge burns himself. Pepper and Josie add that she should make her strongest suit with her style in mind. If Josie can’t release the EP or play gigs, she wonders what kind of career she could possibly have. Katy reveals to Jorge and Josie that she invited Xandra and KO to Pepper’s party. Josie reveals that she loves him as well.At the apartment, Josie introduces Katy to her stepbrother, Josie and the Pussycats rehearse at the studio. Alex arrives right behind them, who Chad is familiar with from Collegiate. They circle around the back of Studio 34, where hey're greeted at the backdoor by Claude. Josie then asks if Pepper ever tried to borrow money from him. Josie notices that he left his coat behind and inside the pocket, she finds a large bag of cocaine. Pepper informs Josie that Alex has agreed to invest in Jorge’s musical but only if Josie agrees to be the Spider Woman. However, Pepper insists that she’s not the source.
It’s then that Xandra reveals her deal with Pepper that ensures that she will play the role of Spider Woman should the play make it to Broadway. However, she’s short. After Katy went after Pepper in the hallways, she comes back in the apartment, where Jorge and Josie comfort her. Josie, Jorge and Pepper help her, trying on numerous outfits in the apartment. Pepper and Josie discuss how she helped Alex get back into rehab and is newly single with no music career or any songs to call her own. This time, she refers to Josie as Marci.
That evening, Katy enters the apartment to find Jorge and Josie in the kitchen. While he won’t talk to her, Xandra hopes he’ll talk to Josie. Raj films each audition.
Alexandra admits it’s a good block, but they’ll have to sell something with better margins. She isn’t quite ready to forgive her. Josie explains that as a woman in the industry, it’s hard to walk into a room and feel like your voice matters enough to be heard. They have to show his dad that they've got something. However, Xandra informs Josie that she recorded her songs under a deal with Cabot Entertainment, and thus they own it. And Josie portrays herself. Jorge tells Katy to be grateful that KO showed up at all for her, as Buzz didn't come for him.